Fan's % stucked in career mode
- #1
Noticed the fans % doesn't increase for many games, either win or lost, ticket price high or low. The fan's percentage stuck at 30% or 24% never goes up no matter how your team performs. BIG bug, it affect the club's income it's no longer fun to play.
Everything works fine for the first time until I reached division 5, the fans % doesn't move at all and stucked at 30%. Started a new game to try, division 10 stuck at 24%. no matter what you do, how good the team perform, it just doesn't change. Man United SG wrote:
Noticed the fans % doesn't increase for many games, either win or lost, ticket price high or low. The fan's percentage stuck at 30% or 24% never goes up no matter how your team performs. BIG bug, it affect the club's income it's no longer fun to play.
Everything works fine for the first time until I reached division 5, the fans % doesn't move at all and stucked at 30%. Started a new game to try, division 10 stuck at 24%. no matter what you do, how good the team perform, it just doesn't change.Continued playing and the % went up for few rounds and it's stucked again at 300 fans for almost half a season of matches. Some time stuck from beginning of the season till end, And the numbers starts climbing for few weeks during the off season. What is wrong with the game??
Man United SG wrote:
Man United SG wrote:
Noticed the fans % doesn't increase for many games, either win or lost, ticket price high or low. The fan's percentage stuck at 30% or 24% never goes up no matter how your team performs. BIG bug, it affect the club's income it's no longer fun to play.
Everything works fine for the first time until I reached division 5, the fans % doesn't move at all and stucked at 30%. Started a new game to try, division 10 stuck at 24%. no matter what you do, how good the team perform, it just doesn't change.Continued playing and the % went up for few rounds and it's stucked again at 300 fans for almost half a season of matches. Some time stuck from beginning of the season till end, And the numbers starts climbing for few weeks during the off season. What is wrong with the game??
Thanks you for your feedback, we will check that out and let you know as soon as possible!
PLH wrote:
Man United SG wrote:
Man United SG wrote:
Noticed the fans % doesn't increase for many games, either win or lost, ticket price high or low. The fan's percentage stuck at 30% or 24% never goes up no matter how your team performs. BIG bug, it affect the club's income it's no longer fun to play.
Everything works fine for the first time until I reached division 5, the fans % doesn't move at all and stucked at 30%. Started a new game to try, division 10 stuck at 24%. no matter what you do, how good the team perform, it just doesn't change.Continued playing and the % went up for few rounds and it's stucked again at 300 fans for almost half a season of matches. Some time stuck from beginning of the season till end, And the numbers starts climbing for few weeks during the off season. What is wrong with the game??
Just tried again an hour ago with the fresh new game after the BETA 3.1 update? The situation same too, now stuck at the following stage at division 10. The fan base number doesn't grow for 5 to 6 games with straight wins.
Capacity
500
Seats today
Fan Base
120
↑↑ Growing Fast
Occupancy
24%
146 expected
Ticket
$1.00- #5↩ Man United SGedited
Man United SG wrote:
PLH wrote:
Man United SG wrote:
Man United SG wrote:
Noticed the fans % doesn't increase for many games, either win or lost, ticket price high or low. The fan's percentage stuck at 30% or 24% never goes up no matter how your team performs. BIG bug, it affect the club's income it's no longer fun to play.
Everything works fine for the first time until I reached division 5, the fans % doesn't move at all and stucked at 30%. Started a new game to try, division 10 stuck at 24%. no matter what you do, how good the team perform, it just doesn't change.Fan base growth depends on several factors, including your infrastructure, staff, players, division (the most important one), and results. One thing I should also clarify is that lowering ticket prices does increase fan support, but this growth is capped depending on those factors i mencioned above.
However, looking at the examples you've shared, we clearly need to review the system across all divisions, not only the growth limits themselves but also how fan distribution is calculated. Something isn't working as intended, and we want to make sure it works consistently throughout the game.
we'll be looking into this. We'll also share an update with you later today.
Thanks for taking the time to share your feedback! We genuinely appreciate it, and we'll keep all your suggestions in mind as we continue improving the game. Once we leave Beta, we'd also love to find a way to show our appreciation to those who've helped us along the way.
In the meantime, we'd be happy to hear any other ideas you have about what we could improve, change, or add to the game. Your input really matters to us!
- #6
Thanks for the detailed report — you were right, and it helped us find the cause.
The weekly calculation pulled every club towards the ordinary crowd of its division and only let results nudge that target a little. That is why clubs in the same division ended up with almost the same number of fans, and why the stadium sat at 20–30% full whatever happened on the pitch.
What changed today (already live):
The fan target now has more parts. Your division is still the biggest one, followed by your results (points per game, table position, recent form and cup wins). Promotion or relegation, club reputation, your stadium and facilities, your squad against the rest of the league, your staff, the fans' mood and the ticket price also count.
-> Cheap tickets still help, but only up to +25%. They can't replace results.
-> Fans move every week, and every result counts straight away. Each week the fan base closes 12% of the gap to the target. A home win, an away win, a draw or a defeat changes the number on the spot.
-> A new panel on the stadium screen, "Why your fans move", shows your target, every factor with its exact value, and what the next result will do.
Over the coming weeks clubs will spread out: the ones that win will gain fans and the ones that struggle will lose some. If your fans still look stuck, please post a screenshot of that panel here and we'll look again.
- #7↩ ManageFC Adminedited
ManageFC Admin wrote:
Thanks for the detailed report — you were right, and it helped us find the cause.The weekly calculation pulled every club towards the ordinary crowd of its division and only let results nudge that target a little. That is why clubs in the same division ended up with almost the same number of fans, and why the stadium sat at 20–30% full whatever happened on the pitch.
What changed today (already live):
Can't seem to attach any screenshots here in forum?
- #8edited
Would you mind joining our Discord? It would be easier to communicate there, and you can share your screenshots with us. I'm there as Admin and my name is @pablito
https://discord.gg/szKFNeEPEP PLH wrote:
Would you mind joining our Discord? It would be easier to communicate there, and you can share your screenshots with us. I'm there as Admin and my name is @pablito
https://discord.gg/szKFNeEPEPThanks Pablito, looks like the issue had been solved as I've tried playing it again and at least the fan's % are moving up and down almost each round of matches.
Now with another problem. As mentioned, I did played till division 7 currently. Some of the players in team contract ending soon and not able to click on the players to negotiate for new contract. Basically click on the player's in profile or from the contract's page which shows all the players contract date. There's no option at all when clicked on the players. Simply put, can't find anyway to sign for new contract with any players in the club.
- #10↩ Man United SGedited
Man United SG wrote:
PLH wrote:
Would you mind joining our Discord? It would be easier to communicate there, and you can share your screenshots with us. I'm there as Admin and my name is @pablito
https://discord.gg/szKFNeEPEPThanks Pablito, looks like the issue had been solved as I've tried playing it again and at least the fan's % are moving up and down almost each round of matches.
nice that is working now! relative to the contracts problem, is something new that we are still working on, so the "contracts" page is just on test mode by now. but we are working on that workspace for the user renew all the contracts, staff included